Mastic Siding Costs, Pros & Cons, Reviews

Typical Cost To Install Vinyl Siding Average: $5,672 - $8,193
See costs in your area

Mastic vinyl siding is made by Ply Gem, the number one home exterior building products manufacturer in the United States.

Mastic siding comes in a wide array of styles and colors to ensure that any homeowner can find the right look for their home exterior. The brand prides itself in providing durable, long-lasting vinyl siding that will remain looking as good as new for years to come.

If you are ready to install new vinyl siding on your home, contact your local siding pros for a FREE ESTIMATE!

Average Cost Of Mastic Siding

To replace old siding on a 1,600 square foot house with Mastic siding, will cost $4,750 – $12,500.

Per square foot, the cost of Mastic siding itself ranges between $2.50 and $8.50, with most projects falling in the $4 to $7 dollar range per square foot.

Your total cost to install new vinyl siding will depend on many factors, such as architectural complexity of your house, local siding installation rates, as well as the type of Mastic siding you choose for your home.

The table below outlines the average cost of Mastic vinyl siding, including material and installation cost. The figures are based on a 120 square foot area.

Basic Mid-Range High-End
Average Price per Square Foot $3.95 $5.40 $7.20
Material Costs $120 – $200 $170 – $250 $240 – $340
Installation Costs $250 – $390 $360 – $520 $500 – $650
Total Cost $370 – $590 $530 – $770 $740 – $990

In terms of quality and design, Mastic vinyl siding is closest to Alside Siding as well as Georgia Pacific vinyl siding.

Professional Cost To Install Mastic Vinyl Siding

Out of all siding types, vinyl siding is actually one of the cheapest, fastest and easiest to install. Siding pros typically charge $2-7 per square foot to install vinyl siding.

Here are some of the factors that impact how much your total installation charges for siding will be:

– Number of stories in your house. If there is more than one storie, you can expect a 40-50% upcharge

– Architectural complexity of the house, including, windows, doors, number of corners, etc

– Ease of access

– Local labor rates. How much installers charge can vary by as much as 30% depending on where you live. High-income areas along the East and West Coasts have some of the higher contractor labor rates in the country. On the other hand, Southern and Mid-Western States have some of the lowest labor rates in the country.

– Cost to remove old siding. Depending on the square footage and type of your existing siding, removing it can cost an additional $1,200 – 3,000

– Asbestos Siding. If your old siding contains asbestos, which is a serious health hazard, removing it can cost up to $10,000

You can use our Vinyl Siding Calculator, to accurately estimate the total cost to replace old vinyl siding on your house.


Cost to Install Siding (1600 s.f)
Vinyl
$8,903
Hardie
$12,245
Wood
$11,267

See costs in your area Start Here - Enter Your Zip Code


Mastic Vinyl Siding Cost vs. Other Vinyl Siding Brands

Many homeowners considering various vinyl siding options wonder how does Mastic vinyl siding compare to other brands price-wise?

Mastic siding is slightly on the upper range of the price spectrum for vinyl siding, costing between $3.50 and $8.50 per square foot on average. Most other vinyl siding brands can be about 10-20% cheaper.

The table below compares the average cost per square foot of some of the most popular vinyl siding brands. The cost in the table only includes the siding itself, not the cost of professional installation, or other associated expenses.

Vinyl Siding Brand Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Mastic Siding $2.50 – $8.50
Georgia Pacific Siding $1.15 – $8.00
Rollex Siding $4.00 – $7.00
Alside Siding $2.50 – $8.50
Town Square Siding $2.00 -$6.50
Wolverine Siding $1.15 – $7.00

If you are looking for an more upscale and durable siding alternative consider fiber cement siding, such as James Hardie, or Allura.

Mastic Vinyl Siding Styles

Ply Gem offers three primary types of Mastic vinyl siding designs: lap siding, vertical siding, and shake and shingle siding. Within each style are subcategories of designs unique to Ply Gem.

Lap Vinyl Siding

Lap siding gives your home a traditional look with its long, flat boards. To prevent water damage, the boards overlap to keep moisture away from the walls underneath the siding.

Lap siding ranges in width between 3 inches and 7 inches wide. Lap Mastic siding is offered in the widest array of design choices to fit your every need.

Structure Home Insulation System:

This design merges durable vinyl with insulating foam that provides unprecedented levels of temperature control as well as durability.

● Environmentally friendly: The insulation reduces the energy you must expend on heating and cooling your home. The siding can also be recycled.
● Durability: Dent resistance and impact resistance as much as 300% more than other vinyl siding options.
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood.
● Anti-Fading: Ply Gem’s Duranyl 5000 protection system provides UV protection against fading and sun damage.
● Available in a range of sizes and styles: Double 4”, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap, Double 6”, Double 6” Dutch Lap Long, Single 7”, Single 7” Long

Quest Vinyl Siding

Designed for maximum strength, the Quest lap vinyl siding is strong enough to withstand tornadoes, hurricanes, and storms.

Top Features:

● Color options: thirteen standard color options available and eleven premium color choices available
● Durability: special technology reduces cracking, denting, impact, and thermal distortion.
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood
● Wind resistance: Can withstand wind speeds as high as 190 miles per hour.
● Tornado resistant design: Nails are protected with a fold-over design system to anchor them in place and prevent damage even in high winds
● Panel locking system: To ensure the siding remains intact even in extreme weather conditions, Ply Gem’s locking system interlocks the siding panels and tightens them in extreme weather conditions, ensuring the siding remains intact during extreme weather conditions
● Panel protection: Extra 3/4” panel protection ensures extra rigidity and durability
● Anti-fading: Ply Gem’s Duranyl 5000 protection system provides UV protection against fading and sun damage
● Weather protection: Ply Gem’s Kynar 500 protection for cedar colors helps retain the color of the cedar style siding for years to come
● Available in a range of sizes: and styles Double 4”, Double 4” long length 16 foot panel, Double 4” super long length 25 foot panel, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap long length 16 foot panel, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap super long length 25 foot panel


Cost to Install Siding (1600 s.f)
Vinyl
$8,903
Hardie
$12,245
Wood
$11,267

See costs in your area Start Here - Enter Your Zip Code


Carvedwood 44 Vinyl Siding

Carvedwood 44 Mastic lap vinyl siding provides a wide range of color choices, including fade-resistant darker shades, to ensure your home matches your aesthetic desires.

Top Features:

● Anti-fading and anti-distortion: 10 Carvedwood colors are offered with SolarDefense anti-fading and anti-distortion technology.
● Color options: Offered in 16 standard color choices and 4 premium color choices ● Deep shadow lines: To mirror the appearance of real wood, panels are designed with a 5/8” panel projection
● Easy, secure installation: the rollover reinforced nail hem streamlines the installation process and ensures that the nails stay in place
● Durability: special technology reduces cracking, denting, impact, and thermal distortion.
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood
● Available in a range of sizes and styles: Double 5”, Single Smooth 8”, Triple Smooth 3”, Double 4”, Double Smooth 4”, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap

Western Extreme Vinyl Siding

Specifically engineered to withstand the weather conditions of the Western United States, the Western Extreme siding is designed to last.

Top Features:

● Durability: Extra thick paneling to prevent denting and ensure strength
● Weather resistant: Designed to withstand all weather conditions, with anti-fading and anti-warping technology to prevent damage from the sun or extreme temperature changes
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood
● Easy installation: Advanced panel locking system streamlines the installation process
● Color options: Offered in 5 standard colors and 11 premium colors
● Available in two sizes and styles: Double 4” and Double 4” DL

Charleston Beaded Vinyl Siding

The Charleston Beaded lap siding recreates the quintessential southern classic wood cupboard siding with a modern twist, ensuring durability and low maintenance for your home’s exterior.

Top Features:

● Charming design: the panels are designed in a quaint southern style.
● Durability: crack resistant and dent resistant panels. Also resistant to thermal distortion from temperature changes.
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood.
● Anti-fading: Duranyl 5000 protection system ensures the siding does not fade from UV rays.
● Easy installation: panel locking system and nail hem allows for streamlined installation.
● Color options: 14 standard color options available.

Ovation Vinyl Siding

The Mastic Ovation line of lap siding stands out for its extensive array of color options, more than any competitor in the same vinyl siding class.

Top Features:

● Color options: 16 standard color options, 1 dark color option, 8 premium color options
● Wind resistance: Can withstand winds as high as 195 miles per hour
● Deep shadow lines: The 9/16” shadow lines give the panels a pleasing, realistic appearance
● Durability: crack resistant and dent resistant
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood
● Anti-fading: five Ovation colors are protected with SolarDefense technology, preventing damage from UV rays such as fading or distortion
● Panel security: Ply Gem’s Snap+Lock+Hold system ensures panels remain in place and remain attached to each other, even in extreme weather conditions such as high winds
● Available in a range of sizes and styles: Double 4”, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap, Double 5”, Single 6.5” Traditional beaded, Triple 3” Brushed

Mill Creek Vinyl Siding

With a unique, textured look, Mill Creek siding gives any building a rustic, natural feel mimicking the look of real wood.

Top Features:

● Durability: crack resistant and dent resistant
● Anti-fading: with the Duranyl 5000 protection system, the siding will not fade from UV rays
● Easy Installation: A panel locking system and nail hem insures that the panels are straightforward to install
● Available in a range of sizes and styles: Triple 3”, Double 4”, Double 4” Dutch Lap, Double 4.5” Dutch Lap, Double 5”, Double 5” Dutch Lap

Eclipse Vinyl Siding

Eclipse siding is an affordable, durable option that requires little maintenance to keep your home looking as good as new.

Top Features:

● Durability: crack resistant and dent resistant
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood
● Anti-fading: with the Duranyl 5000 protection system, the siding will not fade from UV rays
● Easy Installation: A panel locking system and nail hem insures that the panels are straightforward to install
● Color options: 13 standard color options available
● Available in three sizes and styles: Double 4”, 4.5” Dutch Lap, Double 5”


Cost to Install Siding (1600 s.f)
Vinyl
$8,903
Hardie
$12,245
Wood
$11,267

See costs in your area Start Here - Enter Your Zip Code


Mastic Vertical Siding

Vertical siding provides a contemporary appearance to any home. As the vertical panels provide elongation, the style works well for smaller, stout homes.

It is a perfect choice for a full section of siding, as well as for accents such as entryways, porch half-walls, dormers, and gables. Ply Gem offers Mastic vertical siding in one style.

Board and Batten Designer Siding

Elegant vertical paneling provides a modern look while adding visual height to your home.

Top Features:

● Color options: Available in 13 standard colors, 1 dark color, and 5 premium colors
● Durability: Strong paneling prevents cracking, denting, and other impact damage
● Low maintenance: Does not require painting or staining, unlike real wood
● Easy installation: with a nail hem and a panel locking system, installation is secure and streamlined
● Available in one size: 5” boards with 1.5” batten pattern

Mastic Shake and Shingle Siding

Shake and shingle siding, with its beautiful texture, deep shadow lines, and real-wood look, is reminiscent of New England traditional colonial homes. The charming style is best suited for accents, old-style homes, or small homes.

Ply Gem offers shake and shingle Mastic siding in one style.

Cedar Discovery Siding

With real-wood textures, Cedar Discovery mimics the appearance of real wood shake and shingle siding without the burden of maintenance. Cedar Discovery is offered in a range of colors and styles and is designed for durability and strength.

Top Features:

● Color options: Offered in 15 standard color choices and 19 premium color choices
● Wind-resistant: Can withstand windspeeds as high as 180 miles per hour
● Flexible paneling: Ensures easy installation in even the tightest spaces and provides a smooth, seamless appearance
● Double nail hem: Designed to withstand extreme weather such as tornadoes and ensure shakes and shingles remain anchored and intact
● Durability: resistant to scratches, dents, and distortion from sunlight
● Continuous locking system: Keeps shakes and shingles in place and allows for simple installation
● Available in many sizes and styles: Hand split shake, Double 7” shingle, Triple 5” shingle, Half Round

Mastic Siding vs. CertainTeed Vinyl Siding

CertainTeed is another top producer of vinyl siding. CertainTeed siding is known for its range of styles, environmental efforts, and simplicity.

CertainTeed is slightly more expensive than Mastic vinyl siding, costing between $4.50 and $9 per square foot.

CertainTeed makes a particular focus of environmental sustainability and friendliness, including many recourses on their website for reducing carbon footprints as well as pairing with vinyl recycling centers to recycle their vinyl.

While Mastic vinyl siding is also recyclable, the company makes a lower effort to ensure environmental friendliness.

Mastic Vinyl Siding vs Alside Vinyl Siding

Alside vinyl siding is an excellent vinyl siding option, with a large selection of colors and styles, more than offered by Ply Gem Mastic siding.

Alside is especially known for their premium oak siding, which is offered in nineteen colors. The Alside Prodigy line has the thickest insulation offered in the industry. Alside costs about the same as Mastic siding per square foot, between $3 and $8 per square foot depending on the style chosen.

Mastic Vinyl Siding vs Georgia Pacific Vinyl Siding

Georgia Pacific vinyl siding provides similar options to Ply Gem’s Mastic siding. With many style options for horizontal siding, as well as some choices for vertical and shake and shingle siding, both companies have comparable options.
Similar to Mastic siding, Georgia Pacific siding costs between $4 and $7.50 per square foot.

Is Mastic Siding Warranty Any Good?

Most Mastic vinyl siding comes with an impressive limited lifetime warranty. This warranty is transferable if you sell your home, and the new owners are covered under the warranty for fifty years after the original installation of the siding.

How Should I Choose Which Mastic Vinyl Siding Is Right for Me?

With a wide array of styles and types available, attempting to choose which Mastic vinyl siding is best for your home can be overwhelming. Luckily, Ply Gem offers some resources to help simplify the decision making process.

On Ply Gem’s Mastic siding website, they offer an interactive design tool to help you visualize different colors and styles on your home.

They also offer design tips on their website, as well as installation guides for anyone installing their siding DIY.

Is Mastic Vinyl Siding Environmentally Friendly?

Vinyl siding in general is not considered the most environmentally friendly option as it is made from PVC and is not biodegradable.

That being said, some features of Mastic vinyl siding work to undo the environmental issues of the material. For one, if you choose Mastic Vinyl siding with insulation, it will reduce your energy spent on temperature controlling your home, reducing your carbon footprint.

Also, Mastic vinyl siding is lightweight and easy to transport and install, which reduces the carbon emissions expended during the installation process.

Furthermore, Mastic siding is recyclable, so when the lifespan of your siding is finished you may be able to recycle it.

However, vinyl recycling centers are not so common, so it may be difficult to find one in your area and costly to transport the used vinyl.

Where Can I Buy Mastic Vinyl Siding?

Mastic vinyl siding is sold through building material distributors around the country. On their website, Ply Gem has a search tool to allow you to search for providers near your location.

Additionally, Home Depot carries a small selection of Ply Gem Mastic vinyl siding, such as Lap Double 4” by 150” of various colors, costing $175 per carton (covering 11 square feet).

Ply Gem does not offer Mastic siding at Lowe’s.

Customer Reviews Of Mastic Vinyl Siding

Across several different customer review sites, Mastic vinyl siding has a rating of approximately three out of five stars.

Many customers are satisfied with the appearance and lifespan of their Mastic siding. Others appreciate the helpful customer service they received. Other customers appreciate the affordability of the product compared to some other leading vinyl siding brands.

Some homeowners who have installed Mastic siding do have complaints. A common issue is that the vinyl experiences fading, despite the fact that it is marketed as fade resistant.

Others have experienced rippling, warping, and other issues. Design flaws are also a problem for some customers. When issues arise, many customers have difficulty getting coverage under the limited lifetime warranty.

Although Mastic siding is not the most favored vinyl siding brand in the industry and may have some flaws it is, generally speaking, a reliable choice.

Is Mastic Siding Worth It?

Before spending thousands of dollars to replace your old house siding with Mastic Vinyl Siding, its important to figure out whether or not this is a smart investment.

Overall, you can expect about 68-72% ROI when you install new Mastic vinyl siding. This is a decent return on investment and is one of the top exterior remodeling projects.

If you are prepping your house for sale, new Mastic siding is a great way to instantly boost the curb appeal of your house and increase the home resale value by up to 4% without breaking your bank on expensive siding.

If you are staying in your home, you can enjoy all the benefits of vinyl siding, such as ease of cleaning and maintenance, rot and insect resistance, good insulation, and durability that can make you forget about siding replacement for at least the next ten or fifteen years.


Cost to Install Siding (1600 s.f)
Vinyl
$8,903
Hardie
$12,245
Wood
$11,267

See costs in your area Start Here - Enter Your Zip Code



About Leo B

Leo has been a contractor since 2003, specializing in: roofing, siding, general contracting (GC) and residential remodeling. Leo is also a Certified HVAC, Oil & Gas Heating Technician/Installer. In addition to roofing and remodeling, Leo is passionate about Solar, green building and energy conservation, so a lot of my time and energy goes to installing energy efficient heating and cooling systems.


See more about Remodeling Calculator team here


Leave a Comment