Buying Hardwood Flooring from BuildDirect – How I Saved $3000-5000

A major part of my DIY total home renovation project, is installing new hardwoods in my living room, bedroom and office. Many other aspects of the remodel process have revolved around floors, and I needed to finish a number of different things before I could actually start the installation.

For example, I could not start doing the floors until I insulated my post and beam ceilings, and painted all walls. Basically these two were very time-consuming projects that had to be done BEFORE I installed floors, so I would not damage them, and would not have to worry about paint drips on new hardwood.

As the above mentioned steps are nearly complete, I had ordered my new hardwoods from BuildDirect. It took me over a month to select the right products, as my wife and I had to agree on colors, style, and cost (guess whose main priority was color, and whose was cost 🙂 ).

Hickory hardwood floors in living room

Why did we choose BuildDirect?

After much research in local flooring stores and online, we found BuildDirect. What I first liked about them is the ability to get FREE product samples – you can get up to 5 samples free… per order! So we made 7 orders of 5 free samples each – mostly for floors and tile (we ended up buying tile at a brick and mortar tile store with over 50 locations in US, because they had the best look, and it wasn’t that expensive – $2.79/ft)

get-free-hardwood-flooring-samples-at-builddirect

It wasn’t my first choice to go with an online store, because I like to touch and feel the products that I buy – especially those that will cost several thousand dollars. Therefore, my first choice was to go with local flooring stores. But as we started visiting these stores, we discovered that their prices were RIDICULOUS! I mean the very basic Oaks started at around $5-6 per sq. ft. And anything nice like Hickory was in the $7-10 / sq.ft. range – for a 1000 square feet we were looking at over $8000 just in materials, and that is without underlayment, nails, and all the other accessories. Our total would be $10K without labor (since I’m doing everything myself, labor is “free”).

If you want to know how much flooring installation would cost if you hire a contractor, use our Flooring Calculator tool or see our detailed guide about hardwood installation prices.

Next, I started looking at flooring options at Lumber Liquidators (LL), PayLess Floors (local company with 2 stores in Walpole and North Attleboro, MA) and online flooring shops. Both local stores did not have good prices for what I liked, and were still much more expensive that online shops.

Also check out BuildDirect’s Clearance section – you can get some really good deals there

What flooring did we choose for Living Room and Bedroom/Office?

After going through over 20 samples of hardwoods and bamboo floors, we liked Hickory, Jatoba or Brazilian Cherry, and Tiger Stranded Bamboo. Hickory was more that I wanted to spend ($5.19 /sq. ft), but $2 less than local “bargain stores”.

Bedroom and Office: I REALLY loved Tiger Stranded Bamboo, and PayLess floors was selling it for $6-7 / ft, depending on thickness and plank width. BuildDirect sells is for $2.48, and I got it for $2.18/sq ft on sale! So figure that we saved $4/ft.
tiger-strand-bamboo-5-inch-plank

The Tiger Bamboo plank width is 5″, and it is a click-lock floating floor installation, so I won’t have to use nails or glue – this is a big plus for me! The 3/8″ thickness is not great, but colors are solid all the way through, so even if I need to refinish them later, I got plenty to work with! Read about some of the problems with Bamboo flooring

Living Room: As I mentioned – my wife and I really liked Hickory and it was one of the very FEW floors that we both agreed upon, but price was still too high for my liking. So we looked very hard for alternatives in looks, quality and better price. We chose Jatoba (Brazilian Cherry Hardwood) which was $1.60 less, and actually is Hand Scraped hardwood, which I really like for some reason.

jatoba-brazilian-cherry-hardwood-remodelingcalculator-org
Jatoba has very similar color variance to the Hickory, albeit a bit darker, but with over $1000 in cost difference vs cheapest Hickory that we found, and a Hand-Scraped look, and most important – my wife’s approval of color, I went for this.

Flooring Underlayment

For any hardwood installation, you need underlayment. Using pink paper is for amateurs and rental apartments. I wanted the best, at VERY reasonable price. The options are many, but mostly you have synthetic materials, fibers or cork. I really don’t want synthetic underlayment or fibers, so I went for Cork.

cork-flooring-underlay

Cork is actually much cheaper that synthetics / fibers, and is all natural – so no formaldehyde or any other nasty stuff, and I went with a 6mm thickness, so even with some imperfections in my subfloor, I don’t need to do any leveling work. It will also greatly reduce any squeaking noises when we walk. I paid $0.53/sq ft for cork Underlayment – local store prices were about $1/ft.

Total Cost and Savings

So I ordered 492.40 sq ft of Tiger Bamboo, for our bedroom and office, and 595 sq ft of Jatoba for Living / Dining room area, as well as a total of 1100 sq. ft. of Cork Underlay. Here are my costs:

Tiger Bamboo: 492.40 square feet, at $2.18/ft $1,073.43
Jatoba Natural Brazilian Cherry: 595 square feet, at $3.49/ft $2,076.55
6mm Cork Underlayment: 11 rolls (1100 sq ft) at $0.53/ft $583.00
Shipping & Packaging Total: Two shipments (curbside delivery) $759.54
Grand Total: $4,492.52

My Savings vs CHEAPEST found alternatives:

As I said – Tiger bamboo flooring was $6-7 – the cheapest that I found in local stores. Online, the cheapest I found was at GreenGoodsUSA for $3.49, FloorBros sells it for $3.68, CaliBamboo sells it for $4.79 (need to call to get a price quote) and WayFair sells it for over $7/ft! So figure that I saved $645-3500

The Jatoba is pretty unique to BuildDirect, and I had a hard time finding similar product online (in terms of color/looks) but basically Brazilian Cherry 3″ Hardwood goes for about $5 or more. And $5 options are not hand-scraped! So I figure I saved at least $1.50/ft. Hickory, which was our first choice starts at $5.50 for contractor grade, and goes to $7+ for better grades in 3″ width.

Therefore, I saved at least $900 on Jatoba Hardwood, but more like a couple of grand. Because the product I got is Really Nice, top grade, hand scraped 3/4″ hardwood!

And finally 6 mm Cork sells for about $0.79-1.19 per foot, so I saved at least $286 on cork.

My total savings VS online shops (of unknown trustworthiness) is at least $1831, and more in the range of $3000-5000 if we include local budget stores. I am excluding flooring stores in busy shopping areas such as Routes 1 and 9 around Boston, where prices for hardwoods start at $7-9 and go to over $20.

Ordering, Delivery, Product Inspection and other nuances

Flooring Shipment from BuildDirect - Curbside Delivery

So today I received my shipments, and not without hurdles and hiccups. I still need to do visual inspection of the products. There is a lot of important things to talk about, so I want to discuss this in a separate post, which I will publish later today or tomorrow, and if you plan to buy from BuildDirect you should really read it. I will post a link here when the post goes live.

Published/updated on: September 28, 2016

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *